"The $1.8 Million Crime: How Paul Goldsmith's Retail Crime Scam Criminalizes Poverty While Funneling Taxpayer Money to Atlas Network Insiders" - 3 November 2025
Secret advice, $15,711 in unpaid tax, and a coordinated neoliberal attack on Māori disguised as "law and order"
Kia ora e te whānau,
The $2 Million Crime: How Neoliberal Puppeteers Weaponize “Retail Crime” Against Te Tiriti
Tēnā koutou katoa. When Ministry of Justice officials write secret warnings about “concerning behaviour” that they refuse to release, when a chair of a crime advisory group fails to pay $15,711 in withholding tax, and when right-wing parties rake in 17 times more election funding than their opponents to buy policies that criminalize poverty while Māori face prosecution at 11% higher rates—you’re watching a coordinated neoliberal attack on working communities disguised as “law and order.” This essay exposes who profits, who pays, and who’s pulling the strings behind the Coalition Government’s $1.8 million Ministerial Advisory Group for Victims of Retail Crime.
Smoking Gun: Justice Minister Paul Goldsmith received official advice about “concerning behaviour” by advisory group chairman Sunny Kaushal, but the Ministry of Justice refuses to release it, citing legal privilege (RNZ, 2025). Correspondence obtained by RNZ reveals Kaushal failed to submit required tax forms, resulting in $15,711 in unpaid withholding tax to Inland Revenue in November 2024 (RNZ, 2025). Despite this, Goldsmith maintains full confidence in Kaushal, who has invoiced $238,625 over 12 months at $920/day, while three other contractors earn over $1000 daily (RNZ, 2025).
Thesis: The Coalition Government weaponizes “retail crime” panic to advance neoliberal policies that criminalize poverty, expand surveillance capitalism, and violate tikanga—all while funneling millions to well-connected consultants. This benefits wealthy donors and corporations while harming vulnerable communities, especially Māori who face systemic discrimination at every level of the justice system.
Background: The Whakapapa of Neoliberal Crime Politics
The “retail crime crisis” narrative emerges from a coordinated network of right-wing interests financing the Coalition Government. In 2023, National, ACT, and NZ First raised $16.6 million compared to Labour and Greens’ combined $958,000—a 17:1 funding advantage (RNZ, 2024). ACT Party donors include Alan Gibbs, considered ACT’s “godfather,” who has given hundreds of thousands alongside his ex-wife Jenny Gibbs, whose daughter Debbi Gibbs chairs the Atlas Network—a global right-wing think tank network (Mountain Tui, 2024; Reddit NZ, 2024).
Coalition parties (National, ACT, NZ First) raised $16.6 million in 2023 compared to less than $1 million for Labour and Greens combined, showing a funding advantage of over 17:1 for right-wing parties.
Paul Goldsmith himself is ideologically aligned with this network. Described as “possibly the most libertarian or right-wing person to hold the shadow finance portfolio,” Goldsmith wrote biographies of neoliberal figures including Alan Gibbs (Stuff, quoted in Wikipedia). His political identity was shaped by National/ACT MP John Banks—later found guilty of filing false electoral returns—and he has admitted being “brainwashed” by progressive ideas before being “snapped out of it” by right-wing mentors (Mountain Tui, 2024).
Quantified Stakes: Retail crime reportedly costs $2.6 billion annually, with an 85% increase between 2019-2023 and 118,144 reported victimizations in 2023 (Retail NZ, 2023; RNZ, 2024). Yet these statistics mask deeper truths: Māori experience 38% of crime victimization despite being 33% of the 0-18 population, and poverty—not ethnicity—drives these disparities (Ministry of Justice study, cited in NZ Herald, 2021). Māori face prosecution at 11% higher rates and are imprisoned at seven times the rate of non-Māori (Understanding Police Delivery report, 2024; Salvation Army, 2024).
International Context: The Coalition’s policies mirror those promoted globally by the Atlas Network, which has influenced conservative leaders from Margaret Thatcher to Donald Trump to Liz Truss (PSA, 2024). New Zealand’s Taxpayers’ Union and NZ Initiative are official Atlas partners, and Atlas awarded grants of US$75,800 to Australia and New Zealand in 2022 to promote “individual liberty”—code for deregulation, privatization, and attacks on collective rights (PSA, 2024).
Deconstructing the Neoliberal Crime Theatre
The Ministerial Advisory Group for Victims of Retail Crime was established July 11, 2024, with a $1.8 million annual budget funded largely from the Proceeds of Crime fund (Ministry of Justice, 2025). Goldsmith and Associate Justice Minister Nicole McKee—a former firearms lobbyist for the Council of Licensed Firearms Owners before joining ACT two months before becoming third on their list—appointed Sunny Kaushal as chair (1News, 2024; 1News, 2024).
The Ministerial Advisory Group on Retail Crime has a $1.8M annual budget, with chair Sunny Kaushal invoicing $238,625 in the first 12 months, three contractors earning over $1000/day, and $100,000/year for Auckland office space.
Advisory Group Composition: Kaushal leads four members with “extensive expertise across the retail sector”: Michael Hill’s national retail manager Michael Bell, Foodstuffs North Island retail and property general manager Lindsay Rowles, Retail NZ CEO Carolyn Young, and Himanshu Parmar—a former ACT Party electoral candidate for Hamilton who stood in the 2023 election (RNZ, 2024; RNZ, 2025). This composition represents major retailers and partisan political interests—not vulnerable dairy owners.
The Fallacies: The Coalition’s crime narrative deploys multiple logical fallacies:
Appeal to Fear: Catastrophizing retail crime as an existential threat requiring emergency measures, despite crime being driven by poverty and inequality, not insufficient punishment.
False Dichotomy: Framing the choice as either expanded surveillance/harsher penalties or “soft on crime,” ignoring evidence-based prevention.
Begging the Question: Assuming retail crime requires punitive solutions, then using that assumption to justify punitive policies.
Texas Sharpshooter: Cherry-picking crime statistics from 2019-2023 while ignoring that this period included COVID-19 disruptions, smokefree policy impacts on dairy revenue, and Labour government policies the Coalition opposed.
Cui Bono: Security companies, surveillance tech firms, private prison interests, and wealthy retailers benefit from expanded “tough on crime” infrastructure. Māori and poor communities pay the cost through increased criminalization.
Coordinated Pattern: The timing reveals coordination. In February 2025, Kaushal promised “big things coming” (RNZ, 2025). On February 26, 2025, Goldsmith announced citizen’s arrest expansions (Beehive, 2025). On June 30, 2025, shoplifting infringement regimes were announced (Beehive, 2025). On July 2, 2025, trespass law changes were unveiled (Beehive, 2025). In September 2025, the group consulted on allowing retailers to use pepper spray—a restricted weapon (RNZ, 2025).
Named Parties: Justice Minister Paul Goldsmith (National), Associate Justice Minister Nicole McKee (ACT), advisory group chair Sunny Kaushal, advisory group member Himanshu Parmar (former ACT candidate), Prime Minister Christopher Luxon (National), and major corporate retailers Foodstuffs and Woolworths all advance this agenda.
Following the Money, Exposing the Networks
Evidence Trail: The $1.8 Million Question
Kaushal invoiced $238,625 over 12 months at $920/day—the maximum 250 working days annually (RNZ, 2025). Three principal policy advisers earn $1261/day, $1126/day, and $1036/day on contracts ending between September 2026 and February 2026 (RNZ, 2025). The group rents 389 square meters of Auckland office space for $100,000 annually—enough for 38-48 staff based on standard office planning, despite only eight staff working there (RNZ, 2025).
Compare this to Chief Victims Adviser Ruth Money’s rate of $850/day—$70 less than Kaushal (RNZ, 2025). Labour police spokesperson Ginny Andersen questioned this disparity: “Victims should be first and foremost in our justice system... This government is on record saying they want to put victims first. These actions seem to indicate that they’re not” (RNZ, 2025).
In its first three months (March-June 2025), the advisory group spent $507,468.71: $329,900.93 on personnel, $102,788.26 on chair and member fees, $9,605.71 on travel, and $65,173.81 on admin (RNZ, 2025). The Proceeds of Crime fund—meant to address crime-related harm—finances this expenditure (Ministry of Justice, 2025).
Retail crime increased 85% between 2019-2023, costing retailers $2.6 billion annually, with 118,144 reported victimizations in 2023 - but who bears the real cost and who profits from the ‘solutions’?
Rhetoric Versus Reality: The Policies That Harm
Citizen’s Arrest Expansion: Previously limited to nighttime (9pm-6am) offenses with maximum penalties of three years, the Coalition expanded citizen’s arrest to any Crimes Act offense at any time, allowing “reasonable force” including restraints (Beehive, 2025). Retail NZ CEO Carolyn Young—herself an advisory group member—opposed this, warning “people will get hurt or killed” (1News, 2025). The Employers and Manufacturers Association also criticized the changes as dangerous. International comparisons show Australia’s citizen’s arrest laws resulted in deaths in Frankston and Heathcote, and studies indicate police worldwide discourage such interventions (Wikipedia; Criminal Lawyers Australia, 2024).
Shoplifting Infringement Regime: Stealing goods worth up to $500 carries fines up to $500; over $500 incurs fines up to $1000 (Beehive, 2025). A new “aggravated theft” offense applies when theft under $2000 is conducted in an “offensive, threatening, insulting, or disorderly” manner. Maximum sentences increase to one year for theft under $2000, seven years for theft over $2000. As a strict liability offense with reverse onus, defendants must prove a “reasonable excuse”—shifting the burden of proof (Newstalk ZB, 2025).
Who Can Pay? People stealing food cannot pay $500 fines. This creates a debt spiral leading to further criminalization—exactly what happens to Māori disproportionately. Between March-May 2025, police failed to investigate 5,454 shoplifting complaints under $500 due to a directive later reversed by Police Commissioner Richard Chambers (RNZ, 2025). In Auckland, only 73 of 927 complaints were assigned; in Canterbury 192 of 742; in Wellington 131 of 694 (RNZ, 2025).
Trespass Law Changes: Maximum trespass periods increase from two to three years, fines double from $1000 to $2000 for refusing to leave, and franchises can ban individuals from all locations (Beehive, 2025). Indian business leaders expressed skepticism. Jaspreet Kandhari of NZ Indian Business Association called them “merely an extension” of existing laws, noting “the actual impact will happen when it comes down to enforcement” (RNZ, 2025). Rajesh Goel of Auckland Indian Retailers Association questioned police capacity: “In South Auckland, we have a lot of problems with homelessness and people with mental health issues. We can’t just keep issuing trespass notices” (RNZ, 2025).
Pepper Spray Proposal: The advisory group consulted on allowing retailers to use pepper spray—currently a restricted weapon in New Zealand—for self-defense (RNZ, 2025). This proposal faces “stiff opposition” over safety concerns. Retail NZ’s Carolyn Young, an advisory group member, indicated her organization’s position was clear against it. The proposal remains secret—the Ministry and Minister’s office refuse to release recommendations about “personal safety aides” including pepper spray (RNZ, 2025).
Facial Recognition Technology: Goldsmith supports being “as enabling as he can” in allowing facial recognition technology for retail crime, despite acknowledging “tensions” with privacy rights (NZ Herald, 2025). Foodstuffs North Island trialled FRT in 25 supermarkets, scanning 226 million faces (RNZ, 2025). Privacy Commissioner Michael Webster found the technology “compliant” but warned of “significant privacy concerns” including misidentification, technical bias reinforcing inequities, and surveillance potential (RNZ, 2025). The technology was not trained on New Zealand’s population and could not guarantee no technical bias against Māori and Pacific peoples. Foodstuffs’ own research estimated 900 shoppers yearly could be misidentified in its stores alone. A Māori Reference Panel opposed FRT use in supermarkets given their essential service role and the supermarket duopoly limiting alternatives (RNZ, 2025).
Historical Pattern: Neoliberalism’s Racist Roots
This continues decades of neoliberal policy harming Māori. Deputy Prime Minister Winston Peters stated in 2018 that New Zealand had suffered “thirty-three confused years” of “unbridled, irrational neoliberalism” since 1984, transforming “one of the most egalitarian societies in the world, into a case-study of acute inequity” (Beehive, 2018). New Zealand’s wealthiest 1% now hold nearly one-third of the nation’s wealth. Peters noted: “The squalid garages of parts of South Auckland, to the footpaths in our cities, all the way up to the impoverished communities of Northland, are testament to a failed economic vision” (Beehive, 2018).
Yet the Coalition—including Peters’ NZ First—advances this same neoliberal logic. Between 2011 and 2018, the gap between Māori and non-Māori youth arrests grew dramatically: in 2018, over 66% of the 11,000+ young people arrested were Māori compared to just under 40% in 2011 (RNZ, 2019). An independent 2024 report found “bias” and “structural racism” within police, with being Māori increasing prosecution likelihood by 11% compared to NZ Europeans when all other variables remained constant (RNZ, 2024). Emmy Rākete, lecturer in criminology at University of Auckland and spokesperson for People Against Prisons Aotearoa, stated: “From Moana Jackson’s He Whaipaanga Hou report in the 1980s through every decade since then the New Zealand police have been shown that they engage in racist discrimination against Māori, the New Zealand police apologise for engaging in racist discrimination against Māori and the police go straight back to engaging in racist discrimination against Māori” (RNZ, 2024).
The Oranga Tamariki system shows similar patterns: Māori children face stark overrepresentation and poorer outcomes at every level, with tamariki Māori aged 10-13 less likely to receive warnings or alternative action and more likely to be prosecuted or referred to family group conferences than others (RNZ, 2025). The Independent Children’s Monitor found this overrepresentation is “a clear indicator the system is not performing” (RNZ, 2025).
Hidden Connections: The Networks of Power
Connection 1: Paul Goldsmith to Atlas Network via Alan Gibbs
Goldsmith wrote a biography of Alan Gibbs, ACT’s “godfather” who instructed ACT to be “more radical” and remains a mega-donor to David Seymour (Mountain Tui, 2024). Gibbs is an Atlas Network participant, whose daughter Debbi Gibbs holds a global leadership role in Atlas—”the same network group behind Donald Trump and Liz Truss” (Mountain Tui, 2024). Atlas Network promotes “free market” policies that translate to attacks on climate action, indigenous rights, and trickle-down economics (PSA, 2024).
Connection 2: ACT Party to Firearms Lobby via Nicole McKee
McKee was spokeswoman for the Council of Licensed Firearms Owners (Colfo) before joining ACT just two months before becoming third on their list in 2020 (1News, 2024). As Associate Justice Minister responsible for firearms, she maintains close contact with Colfo, with her office’s written messages including disparaging remarks about Police Association president Chris Cahill, invitations for Colfo to fill her diary, and sending Colfo ministerial releases in advance (NZ Herald, 2024). This led to accusations she is “in the pocket of the gun lobby.” McKee co-leads the retail crime advisory group alongside Goldsmith.
Connection 3: Advisory Group Member Himanshu Parmar to ACT Party
Parmar stood as ACT’s electoral candidate for Hamilton in 2023 and is now vice-chair of the Dairy and Business Owners Group and an advisory group member (RNZ, 2024; RNZ, 2024). This creates a direct pipeline from partisan ACT interests to government policy recommendations.
Connection 4: Coalition Donors to Corporate Retailers
Graeme Hart’s Rank Group donated $446,000 to ACT, National, and NZ First in 2023 (RNZ, 2024). Trevor Farmer donated $300,000 across the same three parties. Warren Lewis gave National $500,000—the largest single donation since 2014. Private equity firm Christopher and Banks contributed $200,000 to National. These donors have direct interests in “law and order” policies that protect property over people.
Connection 5: Proceeds of Crime Fund to Advisory Group
The advisory group’s $1.8 million annual budget comes from the Proceeds of Crime fund, established to “address crime-related harm” (Ministry of Justice, 2025). The fund had $72 million as of November 2022 before $35 million was paid to China in an asset-sharing agreement, cutting it by more than half (RNZ, 2023). Using seized criminal assets to fund consultant fees for a group proposing punitive policies creates a perverse incentive: more criminalization generates more seizures funding more criminalization.
Connection 6: Surveillance Capitalism and Facial Recognition
Twelve major retailers—Foodstuffs, Woolworths, Briscoes, Bunnings, Mitre 10, Michael Hill, Farmers, The Warehouse, One NZ, Spark—signed a statement supporting facial recognition technology after Privacy Commissioner gave a “cautious tick” to Foodstuffs’ trial (RNZ, 2025). These corporations profit from surveillance infrastructure while Māori and Pacific peoples face disproportionate misidentification risks. The technology industry selling FRT systems has a direct financial interest in expanded “retail crime” policies creating demand for their products.
Connection 7: Taxpayers’ Union to Atlas Network
The Taxpayers’ Union, led by Jordan Williams, is an official Atlas Network partner receiving training and funding, including a US$10,000 award from Atlas for campaign work (RNZ, 2024). The Taxpayers’ Union consistently advocates for policies aligned with the Coalition’s agenda: cutting government spending, opposing “co-governance,” promoting “law and order” rhetoric. Sir Bob Jones provides rent-free Wellington office space to the Taxpayers’ Union, making him cumulatively their largest donor (RNZ, 2024).
Tikanga Violations: The Cultural Dimension
Every aspect of this agenda violates tikanga Māori:
Whanaungatanga (Relationships/Kinship): The policies fracture whānau relationships by criminalizing poverty-driven theft, separating family members through imprisonment and trespass bans that can exclude people from entire retail chains where they might buy food.
Manaakitanga (Hospitality/Kindness): Expanding citizen’s arrests, on-the-spot fines, and multi-site trespass bans show the opposite of manaakitanga—they show cruelty toward those struggling. Rather than asking why people steal food or necessities, the Coalition increases punishment.
Kaitiakitanga (Guardianship): True kaitiakitanga means protecting the vulnerable. This agenda protects corporate profits over people. Police seized $11.69 million from gangs in Auckland from January-October 2024 (RNZ, 2024)—yet how much wealth has been seized from corporations exploiting workers or evading tax?
Wairuatanga (Spirituality): Māori conceptions of justice emphasize restoration and balance, not retribution. Moana Jackson’s He Whaipaanga Hou report in the 1980s outlined this—yet successive governments including this Coalition ignore it, choosing punishment over healing.
Kotahitanga (Unity): The policies divide communities by pitting retailers against poor people, security guards against shoppers, creating an “us versus them” mentality that fractures social cohesion. Meanwhile the wealthy donors funding these policies remain invisible.
Rangatiratanga (Self-determination): By criminalizing Māori at disproportionate rates through facially neutral but structurally racist policies, the Coalition undermines Māori self-determination and autonomy. Te Tiriti promised rangatiratanga—this agenda delivers incarceration.
Aroha (Compassion): There is no aroha in fining hungry people $500 for stealing food, in allowing citizens to physically restrain shoplifters, in scanning every supermarket visitor’s face with technology that misidentifies Māori. This is the opposite of aroha.
Who Profits: Names and Amounts
- Sunny Kaushal: $238,625 over 12 months, potentially up to $230,000 annually at maximum contract utilization.
- Three principal policy advisers: Approximately $800,000+ combined annually at rates of $1036-$1261/day.
- Office landlord (unnamed): $100,000 annually for 389sqm Auckland space.
- Security technology companies: Undisclosed profits from selling surveillance equipment, facial recognition systems, pepper spray, and other “crime prevention” products to retailers and government.
- Major retail corporations: Foodstuffs and Woolworths benefit from taxpayer-funded policy development serving their interests, plus justification for surveillance infrastructure and reduced labor costs through automation.
- Coalition donor class: Political access and favorable policies in exchange for $16.6 million in 2023 donations, buying influence over law and order policy that protects their wealth.
Implications: Quantified Harm and Threatened Rights
Quantified Harm to Māori:
- 11% higher prosecution likelihood simply for being Māori (Understanding Police Delivery report, 2024)
- 7 times higher imprisonment rate compared to non-Māori (Salvation Army, 2024)
- 38% of crime victimization burden despite being 33% of youth population (Ministry of Justice study)
- Stark overrepresentation in state care with poorer outcomes at every system level (Oranga Tamariki report, 2025)
- Higher likelihood of misidentification by facial recognition technology not trained on NZ population (Privacy Commissioner inquiry, 2025)
Threatened Rights:
- Privacy: Facial recognition technology scanning 226 million faces, with 99.999% deleted within one minute but creating a surveillance infrastructure normalizing constant monitoring (RNZ, 2025)
- Due Process: Strict liability shoplifting offenses with reverse onus shift burden of proof to defendants (Newstalk ZB, 2025)
- Bodily Autonomy: Expanded citizen’s arrest powers allowing physical restraint by untrained civilians create risks of injury or death, as seen in Australian cases (Criminal Lawyers Australia, 2024)
- Access to Essential Services: Multi-site trespass bans can exclude people from all stores in a retail chain in a duopoly market with limited alternatives (Māori Reference Panel concern, cited by Privacy Commissioner)
International Precedents: The United Kingdom’s “austerity” policies promoted by Atlas Network member Institute of Economic Affairs led to increased poverty, inequality, and social harm (George Monbiot, cited in PSA article). Argentina’s Javier Milei, also Atlas-influenced, implemented shock policies causing massive suffering. Trump’s America shows where this trajectory leads: mass incarceration, surveillance states, and wealth concentration.
Call to Action with Targets:
- Demand transparency: OIA the full advice about Kaushal’s “concerning behaviour” and pepper spray recommendations. Contact Justice Minister Paul Goldsmith’s office demanding release of all advisory group recommendations and advice. Email: p.goldsmith@ministers.govt.nz
- Challenge the advisory group’s legitimacy: Submit on any legislation arising from their recommendations, highlighting the conflicts of interest, lack of diverse representation, and evidence base. Organize petitions calling for the group’s disbandment.
- Oppose surveillance expansion: Contact the Privacy Commissioner supporting stronger protections against facial recognition technology. Join campaigns by privacy advocates and Māori organizations opposing FRT in essential services.
- Support affected communities: Fund and volunteer with organizations like People Against Prisons Aotearoa, JustSpeak, and Māori justice reform groups providing alternatives to punitive responses.
- Vote them out: Remember this agenda at the next election. The Coalition raised 17 times more than Labour and Greens combined—counter this with people power, door-knocking, phone-banking, and organizing in communities harmed by these policies.
Conclusion: Summary, Specific Actions, Moral Clarity
The Ministerial Advisory Group for Victims of Retail Crime is not about protecting dairy owners or small businesses—it’s about funneling $1.8 million annually to well-connected consultants while advancing a coordinated neoliberal agenda that criminalizes poverty, expands surveillance capitalism, and violates tikanga. Justice Minister Paul Goldsmith received secret advice about “concerning behaviour” by chair Sunny Kaushal, who failed to pay $15,711 in withholding tax, yet maintains his position invoicing $238,625 over 12 months. Three contractors earn over $1000 daily while the group rents 389sqm of office space for $100,000 yearly—all funded by the Proceeds of Crime fund meant for crime prevention.
The Māori Green Lantern Fighting Misinformation And Disinformation From The Far Right
The policies they produce—expanded citizen’s arrests allowing physical restraint of shoplifters, on-the-spot fines up to $1000 for stealing food, three-year multi-site trespass bans, pepper spray for retailers, facial recognition technology scanning millions of faces—harm vulnerable communities while enriching security companies, tech firms, and major retailers. Māori face prosecution at 11% higher rates, imprisonment at seven times the rate of non-Māori, and overrepresentation at every level of the justice system driven by poverty and structural racism, not criminality.
The network behind this is clear: Atlas Network-connected donors including Alan Gibbs and his family fund ACT and National to the tune of millions; Paul Goldsmith wrote biographies of these neoliberal figures and is described as possibly the most right-wing person to hold senior National roles; Nicole McKee moved from firearms lobby to government minister in two months; Himanshu Parmar went from ACT candidate to advisory group member. The Coalition raised $16.6 million in 2023 versus Labour and Greens’ $958,000—a 17:1 advantage buying policies that protect wealth over people.
Specific Actions: Email Justice Minister Paul Goldsmith demanding transparency. Submit against any legislation from this advisory group. Support organizations offering restorative justice alternatives. Join campaigns opposing facial recognition technology. Organize in your communities. Vote for parties committed to addressing poverty and inequality, not criminalizing it. Remember the whakapapa of neoliberalism’s harm—from Rogernomics to Ruthanasia to this Coalition—and choose differently.
Moral Clarity: A society is judged by how it treats its most vulnerable. This Coalition, funded by the wealthy and ideologically captured by Atlas Network neoliberalism, has chosen surveillance over support, punishment over prevention, corporate profits over people’s dignity. When someone steals food, the question should not be “How do we punish them?” but “Why do they need to steal food?” When retail workers face violence, the question should not be “How do we arm them with pepper spray?” but “What conditions create that desperation?”
Māori have borne the brunt of neoliberal violence for 40 years. Emmy Rākete was right: “Our people don’t need any more apologies, our people don’t need any more reports, our people need social and economic justice and we need the rangatiratanga that was promised to us in Te Tiriti” (RNZ, 2024).
This Coalition will not deliver that justice. But we can demand it, organize for it, and build toward it. The choice is ours.
Kia kaha, kia māia, kia manawanui.
Koha Request
If this mahi has been useful to you and you have the capacity and capability, please consider supporting this work through koha: HTDM: 03-1546-0415173-000. Only give if you can—solidarity and sharing this research are equally valuable.
Ivor Jones - The Māori Green Lantern
References
All citations are hyperlinked inline throughout the essay. Major sources include:
RNZ reporting on the Ministerial Advisory Group (2024-2025)
Ministry of Justice official documents and Proceeds of Crime fund information
Political donations data from Electoral Commission (2023)
Research on Māori overrepresentation in justice system (Understanding Police Delivery report 2024, Salvation Army State of the Nation 2024, Oranga Tamariki monitoring reports 2025)
Privacy Commissioner inquiries into facial recognition technology (2025)
Atlas Network research from PSA and investigative journalism (2024)
Historical documents on neoliberalism’s impact (Deputy PM Winston Peters speech 2018, academic research)
Coalition government policy announcements and Cabinet papers (2024-2025)
- Minister-warned-of-crime-advisory-group-chair-s-concerning-behaviour-RNZ-News-11-03-2025_09_51_PM.jpg
- https://www.1news.co.nz/2024/07/14/govt-wants-to-clarify-how-shopkeepers-can-defend-their-property/
- https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/politics/firearms-minister-nicole-mckee-wanted-the-gun-registry-gone-a-review-says-otherwise/TYZEOD6AJRH3BIGXIBIQUR3LJY/
- https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/politics/the-varied-faces-of-think-tanks-in-nz-who-fronts-them-and-what-they-do/X7M4SUFDT5GYHKTJI2JCTJPUMA/
- https://www.1news.co.nz/2024/08/12/gun-reform-stoush-who-is-nicole-mckee/
- https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/indonz/528354/government-confirms-members-of-advisory-group-on-retail-crime
- https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/indonz/521448/our-lives-don-t-matter-indian-businesses-want-action-on-violent-retail-crime
- https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/politics/unnecessary-disproportionate-unjustified-government-backs-off-5-year-trespass-notices-but-concerns-remain/JWP4T4EUN5C3FGQSPBVRG2LWAI/
- https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/crime/fighting-crime-needs-the-team-of-five-million-sunny-kaushal/LMKW4NG65RBWXNT6C4245Q55RQ/
- https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/national/572917/advisory-group-wants-retailers-to-be-allowed-to-use-pepper-spray-a-restricted-weapon
- https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/dairy-owners-cant-sell-cant-leave-and-want-to-leave-the-country-following-workers-death/CEVNUWW24RGLPM6DZHS5FRRSHA/
- https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/politics/justice-minister-paul-goldsmith-announces-new-citizens-arrest-powers/TM5ZHJMHKVEGPFEDND7QYJ3A6I/
- https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/politics/counterintuitive-police-slam-govt-citizens-arrest-proposal-as-giving-public-more-power-than-cops/7YYHDHLKMRAQVHURHUKVRIGYGM/
- https://www.rnz.co.nz/news
- https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/national/577671/minister-warned-of-crime-advisory-group-chair-s-concerning-behaviour
- https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/despite-crime-wave-80-per-cent-of-dairies-could-fold-anyway-due-to-smokefree-2025/4YYKY673RRBH7FPA2MOUNTZRRU/
- https://www.1news.co.nz/2025/02/26/citizens-arrests-retail-group-says-people-will-get-hurt-or-killed/
- https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/its-not-sexy-but-expert-blueprint-on-organised-crime-is-a-no-brainer-for-coalition-government-jared-savage/7HS3LSIHCNGURLL27R5AGTL4FQ/
- http://supermarketnews.co.nz/features/20-minutes-with-sunny-kaushal-the-dairy-and-business-owners-group/
- https://www.justice.govt.nz/justice-sector-policy/ministerial-advisory-group-for-victims-of-retail-crime/
- https://defsec.net.nz/2024/08/15/government-creates-retail-crime-advisory-group/
https://www.dairyowners.org.nz
- https://www.thelawyermag.com/nz/news/general/justice-minister-announces-legal-reforms-aimed-at-curbing-retail-crime/526663
- https://taupochamber.co.nz/events/retail-crime-meeting/
- https://www.rnz.co.nz/tags/crime
- https://www.facebook.com/RadioNewZealand/posts/there-are-concerns-about-the-head-of-a-government-group-set-up-to-combat-retail-/1288987153267230/
- https://www.facebook.com/KaushalNZ/
- https://www.beehive.govt.nz/release/more-tools-businesses-deal-retail-crime
- /content/files/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/retail-nz-report-on-retail-crime-2024.pdf
- https://www.facebook.com/RadioNewZealand/posts/the-final-report-from-an-advisory-group-on-organised-crime-is-calling-on-the-gov/1272809361551676/
- /content/files/system/files/2024-08/h2024037082_am_-_meeting_with_dairy_and_business_owners_group_chair_sunny_kaushal.pdf
- https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/minister-warned-of-crime-advisory-group-chair-sunny-kaushals-concerning-behaviour/AQWHSKML2NGCPD446DLLWCB5OM/
- https://www.police.govt.nz/about-us/publications/corporate/information-releases?field_publication_category_tid=All&items_per_page=60&title=&edit-submit-publications=Go
- https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/political/521869/government-sets-up-two-year-advisory-group-on-retail-crime
- https://www.1news.co.nz/2020/02/19/goldsmith-reiterates-sfo-charges-over-donations-to-national-dont-relate-directly-to-us-during-john-campbell-interview/
- https://www.1news.co.nz/2023/04/21/race-relations-commissioner-donated-thousands-to-labours-kiri-allan/
- https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/national
- https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/national/528134/watch-christopher-luxon-holds-post-cabinet-press-conference
- https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/top/526281/treaty-negotiations-minister-defends-5-percent-of-coastline-comment
- https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/political/520591/justice-minister-paul-goldsmith-confirms-coalition-plans-to-amend-sentencing-laws
- https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/politics-and-money-poll-gives-a-big-fat-no-to-taxpayers-funding-political-parties-instead-of-donations/2QQUIYTZRMK6RZDFQ4PVJSFIMA/
- https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/political/528460/coalition-s-gang-legislation-passes-into-law-banning-patches-in-public-places
- https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/politics/major-electoral-law-overhaul-includes-ending-same-day-enrolment-clarity-on-treats-for-voters/6MR5XYITBJF5ZJIGY3DGKCK2IM/
- https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/political/556291/opposition-cries-foul-over-tougher-sentencing-laws
- https://www.ird.govt.nz/income-tax/withholding-taxes/resident-withholding-tax-rwt
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paul_Goldsmith_(politician)
- https://www.national.org.nz/news/20250226-paulgoldsmithretailcrime
- https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/political/557609/increasingly-vulnerable-warning-over-rise-of-organised-crime-in-nz
- https://www.facebook.com/RadioTaranaNZ/posts/there-are-concerns-about-the-head-of-a-government-group-set-up-to-combat-retail-/1163087972590582/
- https://www.beehive.govt.nz/minister/biography/paul-goldsmith-0
- https://www.national.org.nz/policies/real-consequences-for-crime
- https://www.brcturkiye.com/sirali-sistem?s-news-4623919-2025-11-03-controversy-surrounds-leadership-and-funding-of-retail-crime-advisory-group-in-new-zealand
- https://www.rnz.co.nz/tags/Ministerial Advisory Group on Organised Crime
- https://nz.linkedin.com/in/paul-goldsmith-07b19380
- https://www.national.org.nz/news/20250701-hon-paul-goldsmith-protecting-retailers-from-shoplifting
- https://www.ird.govt.nz/income-tax/withholding-taxes/schedular-payments/making-schedular-payments/deductions-from-payments-to-contractors
- https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/national/512404/retail-crime-reports-up-20-percent-on-last-year-police-data-shows
- https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/indonz/542958/labour-criticises-retail-crime-advisory-group-spend
https://www.rnz.co.nz
- https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/business/568519/retail-nz-says-members-will-be-devastated-by-theft-incidents-not-being-investigated
- https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/indonz/542158/government-considering-big-measures-to-tackle-retail-crime
- https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/business/568548/significant-boost-expected-in-police-retail-crime-probes-after-rethink-on-cash-limits
- https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/indonz/513552/indian-community-disappointed-by-government-s-quarterly-action-plan-on-crime
- https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/business/570246/retailers-not-reporting-crime-because-they-don-t-believe-police-will-turn-up
- https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/indonz/565650/indian-business-community-welcomes-tougher-shoplifting-penalties
- https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/police-data-reveals-2024-retail-crime-spike-business-group-says-situation-continues-to-worsen-despite-govt-promises/O5Q57T6R4NAWVICFI2CK45NCRI/
- https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/indonz/528866/indian-community-failing-to-see-tangible-results-on-crime
- https://www.psa.org.nz/journals/understanding-atlas-how-a-right-wing-network-is-building-global-influence
- https://integratedsecurity.co.nz/how-does-retail-crime-affect-local-businesses-in-new-zealand/
- https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/political/567082/retail-crime-advisory-group-costs-500k-in-three-months
- https://www.police.govt.nz/about-us/publication/retail-crime-and-ram-raids
- https://www.abc.net.au/news/2025-04-24/atlas-network-think-tanks-active-in-australia-and-new-zealand/104788732
- https://www.indianweekender.co.nz/news/govt-confirms-members-of-advisory-group-on-retail-crime
- https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/te-manu-korihi/526029/report-finding-bias-and-structural-racism-in-nz-police-unsurprising-maori-academic-says
- https://www.nzherald.co.nz/the-listener/politics/david-seymour-on-te-tiriti-power-acts-next-move-his-first-major-interview-before-becoming-deputy-pm/2HREH57RL5DQXFATT6KQ26K4FQ/
- https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/political/467885/police-minister-announces-government-s-crime-prevention-package
- https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/political/563803/oranga-tamariki-report-finds-stark-outcomes-for-maori-in-state-care-system
- https://www.1news.co.nz/2024/07/11/govt-establishes-advisory-group-for-retail-crime-victims/
- https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/simon-wilsons-election-diary-stimulus-or-austerity/WZYJI7BL4B23DOX73GBC6GYZ2E/
- https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/political/577671/minister-warned-of-crime-advisory-group-chair-s-concerning-behaviour
- https://www.nzherald.co.nz/kahu/study-shows-poverty-accounts-for-more-maori-being-victims-of-crime/DGQOHCK7JWRG2RNN2QEM4QK64A/
- https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/letters-covid-19-northern-pathway-second-hand-opinions-and-economy/EWJ6ZJDQMEHGE2PV7AFGB5NRAE/
- https://www.1news.co.nz/2022/05/26/govt-announces-6m-to-help-ram-raided-businesses/
- https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/national/393343/gap-between-maori-and-non-maori-youth-arrests-continues-to-grow
- https://www.beehive.govt.nz/speech/capitalism-human-face
- /content/files/wp-content/uploads/2023/10/retailnz-retailcrimereport2023.pdf
- https://www.beehive.govt.nz/release/proceeds-crime-fund-safety-measures-central-auckland
- https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/politics/as-enabling-as-i-can-justice-minister-paul-goldsmith-backs-facial-recognition-software-to-prevent-shoplifting-despite-privacy-concerns/5W5PRIRXGBA7VBJQT7GSCRMWDM/
- https://www.justice.govt.nz/justice-sector-policy/about-the-justice-sector/proceeds-of-crime-fund/
- https://www.salvationarmy.org.nz/research-policy/social-policy-parliamentary-unit/state-nation-2024/crime-and-punishment/
- https://anthrosource.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1111/j.1548-1433.2008.00075.x
- https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/alert-top/577671/minister-warned-of-crime-advisory-group-chair-s-concerning-behaviour
- https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/in-depth/523415/why-new-zealand-political-donations-have-more-than-tripled
- https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/political/495628/act-s-top-six-the-faces-and-aspirations-aiming-for-government
- https://www.rnz.co.nz/programmes/30-with-guyon-espiner/story/2018938627/jordan-williams-on-what-the-taxpayers-union-really-is-and-who-funds-it
- /content/files/arc/outboundfeeds/sitemap3/2023-07-06.xml
- https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/politics/in-the-pocket-of-the-gun-lobby-firearms-minister-nicole-mckees-messages-with-gun-owners-group-revealed/LOHV3HGCQFGG7JUFTZUHQA73JM/
- /content/files/podcasts/30-with-guyon-espiner.xml
