“Kaitiaki of Truth: Exposing Simeon Brown's Shameful Betrayal of New Zealand's Healthcare Heroes” - 13 July 2025

Kia ora koutou. Greetings to all who defend the mauri of our healthcare system against the colonial violence of neoliberal destruction.

The Māori Green Lantern exposes the cold-hearted deception of a Minister who prioritizes profit over people's lives

Simeon Brown, the newly appointed Health Minister1, has revealed his true character with a shameful post attacking hardworking nurses who are fighting for basic patient safety and fair pay. This neoliberal puppet, who has zero health qualifications or experience, has the audacity to blame healthcare workers for the crisis his government created through deliberate underfunding and systematic destruction.

Brown's pathetic attempt to gaslight New Zealand about the nurses' strike demonstrates the National Party's contempt for our most essential workers. Every single claim in his post is a calculated lie designed to cover up his government's catastrophic failures.

https://www.facebook.com/share/p/1Qf7Lb9Z7w/?mibextid=oFDknk

The Reality Behind the Government's Manufactured Crisis

The Exodus Brown Refuses to Acknowledge

In the year ending March 2024, an unprecedented 38,017 nurses received registration to work in Australia, with 10,620 of these being New Zealand nurses2. This represents a devastating 53% increase from the previous year3. NZNO kaiwhakahaere Kerri Nuku revealed that Māori nurses are fleeing to Australia to escape the heightened racial pressures3 created by this government's anti-Māori agenda.

The Insulting Pay Offer Brown Defends

Brown's claim about "fair pay" is a grotesque insult to struggling healthcare workers. The government offered nurses a pathetic 0.5% pay increase in the first year and 1% in the second year4 - a real wage cut when inflation is running at 2.2% and household living costs have increased 3.8%5.

To put this in perspective, nurses in Australia earn significantly more than their New Zealand counterparts6. In Queensland, first-year nurses earn $80,067 AUD compared to New Zealand's $66,570 NZD6. The average hourly pay for nurses in Australia is $35.28 AUD compared to $29.94 AUD for New Zealand nurses7.

The Staffing Crisis Brown Ignores

Data obtained by NZNO shows that 50% of all day shifts were understaffed across hospital wards in 16 health districts8. Te Whatu Ora data shows over a quarter of nursing shifts fell short of safe staffing targets9.

The human cost is devastating. Nurses report patients being left in pain and soiled beds due to staffing shortages9. Healthcare workers describe 25-50% of shifts being understaffed9.

Brown's Record of Destructive Incompetence

The Transport Minister Who Harmed Public Health

As Transport Minister, Brown made decisions that were directly damaging to public health10. He reduced funding for pedestrian and cyclist safety infrastructure and increased speed limits around schools10 - possibly the first time internationally that safe speed measures have been reversed10. Health professionals and school leaders pleaded with him not to reverse speed restrictions, but he was indifferent to their concerns10.

The Appointment of Failure

Brown was only appointed Health Minister because his predecessor Shane Reti was stripped of the portfolio after being unable to handle the health crisis1. Sources told 1News that Reti had been struggling to deal with the health challenges, and the Prime Minister was so concerned he became involved with health briefings1.

The Government's Systematic Destruction of Healthcare

Cuts Disguised as Investment

Despite Brown's claims about "record investment," the reality is devastating cuts. Health NZ has been forced to cut 1,478 roles, including public health policy advisers, Māori and Pacific health advisers, and IT workers5. The government has axed approximately 653 full-time-equivalent roles from Digital Services, accounting for 33.7% of their workforce11.

Te Whatu Ora's operational budget only increased by $93 million, or 0.4% from estimated actual spending in 2023/2412. This is barely enough to keep the system's head above water12.

The Manufactured Financial Crisis

Labour's health spokesperson Ayesha Verrall revealed that the government manufactured a financial crisis to justify stripping back the health system13. All four regions of New Zealand are receiving between 6-14% less funding than the previous year13.

The government withheld $529 million from Te Whatu Ora to pay nursing, midwifery and allied staff the pay increases they received in 202313. This accounts for a significant chunk of Te Whatu Ora's deficit13.

The Tax Cut Agenda

The finance minister announced $7.47 billion in reduced government spending to fund tax cuts14. This equals one-third of the allocated health budget14.

The Broader Context of Neoliberal Assault

Historical Underfunding

New Zealand's health spending as a share of GDP has remained unchanged since 2010 at about 7%, compared to an average of 12% in similar countries15. According to OECD data, in 2020 New Zealand spent US$3,929 per capita on health - far less than Canada (US$6,215) and Australia (US$5,802)16.

Professor Robin Gauld called the funding situation a "national scandal," noting that if you have money you can go private, but it's the less well-off, Māori and Pacific people who are missing out15.

The Māori Green Lantern fighting misinformation and disinformation from the far right

The Pattern of Targeting Essential Workers

This attack on nurses follows the classic neoliberal playbook - defund public services, create a crisis, then blame the workers who are desperately trying to hold the system together. The government has spent $33 million on health redundancy payouts17, money that could have been spent on patient care.

The Māori Perspective: Defending Our People's Right to Health

From a Māori worldview, health is not just an individual concern but a collective responsibility tied to our whakapapa and whakatōhea. The government's assault on our healthcare system represents a fundamental attack on our people's mauri and mana.

Māori and Pacific health advisers are being cut5, undermining our ability to address the structural inequities that harm our whānau. The government has abolished Te Aka Whai Ora, the Māori Health Authority13, while continuing to cut services for Māori.

The exodus of Māori nurses to Australia represents a hemorrhaging of our people's knowledge and skills, driven by this government's hostile environment and refusal to properly value our healthcare workers.

The Broader Implications: A System in Manufactured Crisis

The Impact on Whānau

The nurses' strike affects approximately 36,000 healthcare workers18, representing the largest industrial action in opposition to the National Party's brutal austerity measures. These are the same workers who put their lives on the line during COVID-1919.

The human cost is immense. Nurses report having to ration care, making patients go without basic personal hygiene to prioritize life-preserving care9. Basic needs like washing a patient's face or helping them to the bathroom are being missed4.

The International Context

New Zealand's health crisis is not unique globally, but our response is uniquely destructive16. While other countries invest in their healthcare systems, we are deliberately starving ours to fund tax cuts for the wealthy.

Call to Action: Defending Our Healthcare System

The nurses' strike is not just about pay and conditions - it's about the fundamental right of all New Zealanders to receive healthcare when they need it. The strike represents a defense of patient safety against a government that has lost control of the health system8.

Brown's attack on these healthcare heroes reveals his government's true priorities: protecting the wealthy while sacrificing the health and wellbeing of ordinary New Zealanders. His shameful post is a disgrace to the office he holds and an insult to every New Zealander who depends on our public health system.

We must stand with our nurses, support their demands for fair pay and safe staffing, and reject this government's neoliberal assault on our healthcare system. The fight for our nurses is a fight for our collective health and wellbeing.

The Choice Before Us

Simeon Brown's post reveals the true nature of this government - cold, calculating, and utterly indifferent to the suffering of ordinary New Zealanders. His victim-blaming of nurses exposes the moral bankruptcy of a neoliberal ideology that values profit over people's lives.

The choice is clear: we can stand with our healthcare workers who are fighting for patient safety and fair treatment, or we can accept the continued destruction of our public health system by politicians who prioritize tax cuts for the wealthy over the health of our people.

The Māori Green Lantern calls on all New Zealanders to support our nurses and reject this government's shameful attack on our healthcare heroes. Kia kaha to all who defend the mauri of our healthcare system.

If you find value in this analysis of the government's assault on our healthcare system, please consider supporting this mahi with a koha to HTDM: 03-1546-0415173-000. The MGL understands these are tough economic times for whānau, so please only contribute if you have capacity and wish to do so.

Ngā mihi nui,
Ivor Jones - Te Māori Green Lantern