Newsletter

“The American Eagle's Talons Grip Our Whenua: FBI Base a Colonial Surveillance Expansion” - 31 July 2025

How Winston Peters and Judith Collins Sold Our Sovereignty to Trump's FBI Hitman

Ivor Jones The Māori Green Ltn

31 Jul 2025 — 18 min read

Kia ora whānau – The eagle has landed, and its talons are digging deep into our sovereign soil.

The establishment of a dedicated FBI base in Wellington represents nothing less than a calculated assault on our tino rangatiratanga. When FBI Director Kash Patel secretly slithered into the Beehive to meet with our captured ministers, he wasn't establishing a partnership – he was installing an occupying force. This decision by the coalition government exposes the depth of their submission to American imperial interests while betraying every principle of indigenous sovereignty that Te Tiriti o Waitangi was meant to protect.

https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/politics/fbi-to-establish-base-in-new-zealand-after-director-kash-patel-visit/HLACKSKCSFCJTO7K4AGVMQWFEY/

Background: The Surveillance State's New Tentacle

To understand this betrayal, we must first acknowledge what the FBI represents. This is not a benign law enforcement agency offering friendly cooperation. The FBI has a documented history of targeting indigenous peoples, civil rights activists, and anyone who threatens the established order. Now, under the leadership of controversial Trump appointee Kash Patel, who has promoted conspiracy theories and vowed to target political opponents, this agency is establishing permanent roots in our whenua.

The broader context reveals the insidious nature of this expansion. New Zealand's participation in the Five Eyes surveillance network has already compromised our independence, with former Prime Minister Helen Clark acknowledging we have lost independence and been "drawn in a lot closer" to the US-led spy network. This FBI base represents the next phase of that colonial surveillance project.

The timing is no coincidence. As China's influence grows in the Pacific, the US is desperately scrambling to maintain its hegemonic control over our region. Our government has willingly offered our sovereignty as a sacrifice to American geopolitical ambitions.

A Foreign Police Force on Our Soil

The scale of this capitulation is breathtaking. Patel explicitly stated that "countering the CCP [Chinese Communist Party]" was one of the "most important global issues" the FBI would address from its Wellington base. Yet Collins dismissed this as merely about "transnational crime", demonstrating either breathtaking ignorance or calculated deception.

The new FBI office will have responsibility for partnerships across New Zealand, Antarctica, Samoa, Niue, Cook Islands, and Tonga. This grants American law enforcement unprecedented reach across our Pacific whānau, turning our government into an instrument of US imperial surveillance.

This matters profoundly to Māori because surveillance has always been a tool of colonial control. From the Armed Police Force established in 1846 to conduct "armed surveillance patrols" in "untamed" (Māori-controlled) areas, to the 2007 Urewera raids targeting Tūhoe, the pattern is clear. Expanding surveillance infrastructure inevitably targets indigenous resistance.

The Kash Patel Problem: America's Own Surveillance Extremist

Understanding who Kash Patel is reveals the sinister nature of this appointment. This is not some career law enforcement professional committed to justice. Patel has faced criticism for promoting conspiracy theories and vowing to target political opponents, including calling investigations into Trump "baseless" and publishing a list of "government gangsters" that critics fear he will use as an enemies list.

Patel's confirmation was one of the closest in recent history, passing by just 51-49, with two Republican senators breaking party lines to vote against him due to concerns about his "prior political activities." Even former Defense Secretary Mark Esper noted that Patel lied about a critical hostage situation.

Most alarmingly, reports suggest Patel spends more time in nightclubs than at FBI headquarters, raising questions about his commitment to the role while simultaneously expanding FBI operations globally. This is the man our government has welcomed to establish permanent surveillance infrastructure on our shores.

The Deeper Surveillance Web: Five Eyes and Indigenous Targeting

The FBI base cannot be understood in isolation from New Zealand's broader participation in the Five Eyes surveillance apparatus. Recent research reveals that New Zealand's role is to provide intelligence on the South Pacific, including "a 'full take' of communications" from our Pacific whānau in countries like Samoa, Fiji, and Tonga – the very nations now falling under this new FBI office's "responsibility."

This surveillance web has already demonstrated its threat to indigenous peoples. Analysis of the 2007 Urewera raids shows how surveillance technologies are used to target Māori political expression, with police conducting over 10 months of illegal covert surveillance on Tūhoe land before launching armed raids that terrorized entire communities.

The pattern extends beyond specific operations. Research shows Māori are systematically over-surveilled through facial recognition technology, with officials admitting they have used biometric systems for years without knowing if they discriminate against Māori. A recent Privacy Commissioner survey found that Māori are more concerned about privacy "in every way" than other New Zealanders, avoiding everything from social media to government contact due to surveillance fears.

Privacy Concerns: Activities Avoided by Māori vs Non-Māori Due to Privacy Concerns

This data reveals the profound impact surveillance has on Māori communities. When one in three Māori avoid contacting government agencies due to privacy concerns, compared to just one in seven non-Māori, we see the chilling effect of the surveillance state on indigenous political participation.

Colonial Policing Continues: From Armed Constabulary to FBI

The establishment of this FBI base represents a continuation of colonial policing strategies that have targeted Māori since 1840. When the first colonial police arrived with Lieutenant-Governor Hobson, their commanding officer noted the "imposing effect which their appearance produces on the Natives" – surveillance and intimidation were always the point.

The Armed Police Force established in 1846 was explicitly modeled on the paramilitary constabulary in Ireland, designed to suppress indigenous resistance through "armed surveillance patrols" in "untamed" (Māori-controlled) areas. Today's FBI base serves the same function – extending imperial surveillance and control over territories that threaten settler-colonial hegemony.

This connection is not historical accident but deliberate strategy. Academic analysis reveals how "digital colonialism" operates through surveillance technologies that replicate colonial control mechanisms. The FBI base provides the infrastructure to expand this digital colonialism across the Pacific, with Māori and Pacific peoples as primary targets.

Sovereignty Betrayed: Peters and Collins' Colonial Collaboration

The response from our government leaders reveals the depth of their colonial mentality. Winston Peters declared New Zealanders should be "grateful" for FBI interest in Wellington, while Judith Collins celebrated that "we were the only one of the Five Eyes partners that did not have an FBI office here" – as if this was a problem rather than a reflection of our supposed independence.

Collins' claim that this is "our sovereign right to do what we do" represents peak colonial doublethink. Inviting foreign police forces to establish permanent bases on your territory is literally the opposite of sovereignty. It's submission disguised as strength, colonization rebranded as cooperation.

Peters' enthusiasm is particularly galling given his supposed nationalism. This is the same man who has built a career opposing foreign influence, yet he personally welcomed the establishment of permanent American law enforcement infrastructure with responsibility spanning from Antarctica to Tonga. The hypocrisy is breathtaking.

Green MP Teanau Tuiono provided the only principled response: "We are not another state of the United States; we shouldn't be allowing foreign powers to be setting up shop like this." This is what sovereignty actually sounds like.

Te Tiriti Obligations Trampled

The establishment of this FBI base violates multiple principles of Te Tiriti o Waitangi. The principle of partnership requires genuine consultation with Māori before decisions affecting sovereignty. Instead, Patel's visit was conducted in secret, only discovered when journalists spotted him in the Beehive basement.

The principle of active protection obligates the Crown to safeguard Māori interests. Expanding surveillance infrastructure that will inevitably target indigenous political expression represents the opposite of protection – it's facilitation of oppression.

Most fundamentally, Te Tiriti guaranteed Māori retained their tino rangatiratanga – their full authority and sovereignty. The Māori version promised Māori would retain their "rangatiratanga" (chieftainship) over their lands and treasures in exchange for granting the Crown "kāwanatanga" (governorship). Allowing foreign law enforcement agencies to establish permanent bases with surveillance authority over our territories represents a complete abandonment of these Treaty guarantees.

Pacific Implications: Imperial Surveillance Expands

The FBI office's mandate extends far beyond New Zealand's shores, encompassing responsibility for "partnerships" across the Pacific. This transforms Wellington into a regional hub for American law enforcement surveillance, with our government acting as willing collaborators in Pacific surveillance expansion.

This development should be understood within the broader context of intensifying geopolitical competition in the Pacific, where the US seeks to counter China's growing influence. Our Pacific whānau become pawns in this great power competition, subject to expanded surveillance from foreign agencies operating through New Zealand's compromised infrastructure.

The Five Eyes network has already demonstrated its willingness to spy on Pacific peoples. Analysis reveals the GCSB conducts "full take" communications surveillance across the Pacific, collecting "every call, message and browse of the internet" from countries like Samoa, Fiji, and Tonga. The FBI base provides additional infrastructure to expand and institutionalize this surveillance of our Pacific whānau.

The Resistance: Māori Values Against Imperial Surveillance

Responding to this assault on our sovereignty requires grounding our resistance in Māori values and worldviews. Whakapapa reminds us that our obligations extend beyond ourselves to our ancestors and descendants – we cannot allow imperial surveillance infrastructure to compromise the safety and sovereignty of future generations.

Whakatōhea teaches us to stand together against threats to our collective wellbeing. The FBI base threatens not just individual privacy but the ability of our communities to organize, resist, and maintain our cultural and political autonomy.

Manaakitanga normally requires us to welcome visitors, but this principle cannot extend to those who come to establish permanent surveillance infrastructure designed to monitor and control our political expression. True manaakitanga sometimes requires refusing hospitality to those who would harm our whānau.

Kaitiakitanga obliges us to protect our territories and peoples from threats. The FBI base represents a clear threat to the political and cultural safety of our communities, particularly those engaged in sovereignty struggles that challenge settler-colonial hegemony.

Digital Colonialism and Māori Data Sovereignty

The FBI base must be understood as part of broader "digital colonialism" that extends imperial control through technological infrastructure. Research shows that surveillance technologies operate as "digital colonialism" that replicates historical patterns of colonial control, with facial recognition and other biometric systems demonstrating particular bias against Māori and other indigenous peoples.

Māori data sovereignty principles, as articulated by Te Mana Raraunga, assert that data about Māori should be subject to Māori governance and control. The FBI base directly violates these principles by establishing foreign surveillance infrastructure with the explicit purpose of collecting and sharing intelligence about activities across New Zealand and the Pacific.

This expansion of surveillance infrastructure will inevitably capture data about Māori political activities, cultural practices, and resistance movements. Under Five Eyes intelligence sharing agreements, this information will be shared with American agencies and potentially used to support US geopolitical objectives that may conflict with indigenous rights and sovereignty.

Implications: The Surveillance State Tightens Its Grip

The broader implications of this FBI base extend far beyond law enforcement cooperation. This represents a fundamental shift in New Zealand's constitutional arrangements, embedding foreign law enforcement infrastructure within our territory while bypassing democratic oversight and Treaty obligations.

The impact on Māori communities will be particularly severe. Historical analysis shows that surveillance expansion consistently targets indigenous political expression, from the Tohunga Suppression Act to the Urewera raids. The FBI base provides additional infrastructure to continue this pattern of surveillance and suppression.

The international implications are equally concerning. By hosting permanent FBI infrastructure, New Zealand becomes complicit in American law enforcement activities worldwide. We risk becoming a staging ground for operations that may violate international law or target legitimate political movements in other countries.

Most fundamentally, this decision reveals the colonial mentality that still governs our political leaders. Rather than asserting independence and sovereignty, they eagerly collaborate in their own subordination, trading away our autonomy for the illusion of security and the promise of continued inclusion in imperial power structures.

Reclaiming Our Sovereignty

The establishment of this FBI base represents a critical juncture in the ongoing struggle for tino rangatiratanga. We face a choice between accepting further integration into imperial surveillance networks or asserting our rights as tangata whenua to control what happens on our territories.

This betrayal by the coalition government demands immediate resistance. We must reject the false choice between American and Chinese hegemony and instead assert our own sovereignty based on Te Tiriti principles and Māori values. Our Pacific whānau deserve protection from surveillance expansion, not subjection to it.

The path forward requires building independent surveillance resistance, supporting Māori data sovereignty initiatives, and demanding the withdrawal of foreign law enforcement infrastructure from our shores. We must also support those Pacific nations seeking to chart their own course free from great power interference.

Most importantly, we must recognize this FBI base for what it truly represents – not enhanced security or international cooperation, but the latest chapter in over 180 years of colonial surveillance and control. Our ancestors resisted the Armed Police Force of 1846, and we must resist its digital descendants today.

The American eagle's talons may have found purchase on our whenua, but they have not yet crushed our spirit. Tino rangatiratanga remains our birthright and our destiny. The struggle continues.

Readers who find value in my content and wish to support the cause of exposing misinformation and defending Māori sovereignty are welcome to consider a koha: HTDM: 03-1546-0415173-000. I understand these are tough economic times for whānau, so please only contribute if you have capacity and wish to do so.

Kia kaha, kia māia, kia manawanui.

Ivor Jones
The Māori Green Lantern

"THE EMPTY TANK: How a White Supremacist Neoliberal Government Left Its Carers on the Side of the Road to Die" - 26 March 2026

“The Pātaka Beside the Strait” - 25 March 2026

"THE PĀTAKA IS ASH: How Nicola Willis and Christopher Luxon Poured Petrol on the Poor and Called It Relief" - 25 March 2026

"THE POISON PEN MINISTER: How Erica Stanford Weaponised the Taxpayer-Funded State Against Her Own Critics — and Why a Wounded Luxon May Be Letting Her Burn" - 25 March 2026